Don's children, Karla, Heidi, Joe, and Chris select 12 women to compete for their father. The contestants face a series of surprise lie detector tests. The ones that passed have to do another elimination process before they meet Don.

In the second episode, Don's four children must eliminate two women to make the total number of remaining contestants five. First, the ladies must to ""secret tasks"" which they must complete or ""dirty secrets"" will be revealed about them. Finally, Don spends one-on-one time with the ladies in the pool and then the kids decide which women will take the lie detector tests.

The siblings try to determine which of the contestants is vain and fastidious during a jaunt to the beach.

In the fourth episode, three women are left to compete for Don and his childrens' hearts. Don takes the ladies on one-on-one dates. The kids also plan trips for the ladies which will require their patience, stamina, and effort. If the girls fail a required task, a ""dirty secret"" will be revealed about them. These trips include a paintball fight, fishing, and a trip to an amusement park. The family and the three finalists then eat chinese food together. Following the meal, fortune cookies are served. Each of the cookies has either a ""dirty secret"" in it or a good fact. Each of the women take a cookie and then must read the fortune aloud. A fax then arrives which says that the kids must choose two women who they feel are the least compatible with their father and have them take out the trash. The three ladies are interviewed and then two of them are chosen. The two chosen must also take a lie detector test. At the end of the episode, a contestant is eliminated leaving only tw

The last episode starts off with the kids eating a meal. Then everyone goes to the pool. Don and Christy are in the pool flirting. Feeling akward watching Don flirt, the kids take Christena to the trampoline to have some fun. Since the kids, are still unsure of who to pick to marry their dad they decide to talk to Don. He says he is attracted to Christy physhically but to Christena by mind and soul. Don the goes on a date with Christy. They go to a private room and talk. The kids are watching them on their tv. Don asks Christy what she thinks of the kids. She says Karla is very sweet and is like a mother. She says that Heidi has a lot of style and that the boys are cute and masculine. The kids then decide that they want to interview each women to get a better feeling about why they feel they should be chosen. Christena says that she would love for Don's children to meet her kids. She also says that she is very attracted to Don and thinks he is an amazing man. She then sta

The girls must find the perfect husband for their father Marty. Marty goes undercover as a jewelery salesman in order to find the true intentions of the contestants. Three girls are eliminated and there is a surprise twist at the end!

When the Ladies discover a note explaining that Marty's sister-in-law has infiltrated the group to gain inside information, they are horrified. The girls begin to point fingers and fights break out. The girls watch their dad flirt and kiss while they use a series of lie-detectors to eliminate the next girl.

Marty and the contestants go on a skeet shooting adventure. To their surprise for every shot they miss, ""dirty secrets"" are told about them. Everyone celebrates Marty's birthday while two women are eliminated. After the party, Marty tells the remaining five women that the show will not end with a proposal, but a WEDDING!!!

In this episode the girls go and pick out their wedding gowns.

Only Stacy, Marilyn and Suzanne remain. And so at the end Marilyn leaves.

In the Season Finale Suzanne and Stacy compete. Suzanne and Stacy had to present their final pleas to both Marty and the girls. Suzanne spoke from her heart about the amazing family she'd come to love over such a short period of time. And that night Marty picked to marry Stacy. The show ended with a kiss.