Mistress America: Cast

Greta Gerwig
Brooke Cardinas

Lola Kirke
Tracy Fishko

Matthew Shear
Tony

Jasmine Cephas Jones
Nicolette

Heather Lind
Mamie-Claire

Michael Chernus
Dylan

Cindy Cheung
Karen

Kathryn Erbe
Stevie

Dean Wareham
Harold

Shana Dowdeswell
Ruth
Shelby Rebecca Wong
Laura
Alfred Macadam
Professor #1

Amy Warren
Counselor

Sharon Washington
Professor #2
Morgan Lynch
Student
Andrea Chen
Hallway Girl

Shoba Narayan
Hallway Girl
Colin Stokes
Mobius Guy

Juliet Brett
Tiny Girl
Gretchen Young
Work Study Woman

David Longstreth
The Band
Amber Coffman
The Band
Steven Marion
The Band
Michael Daniel Johnson
The Band
Nat Baldwin
The Band

Rebecca Naomi Jones
Party Hostess

Mickey Sumner
Fake Brooke
Mary Beth Minthorn
Cycling Class Student

Clare Foley
Peggy

Rebecca Henderson
Anna Wheeler
Kareem Williams
Kareem
Frank Iacuzzo
Psychic
Jessie Austrian
Pregnant Book Club Member
Taryn Simon
Pregnant Book Club Member
Casey Leigh Atre
Pregnant Book Club Member
Andrea Teasdale
Pregnant Book Club Member
Marina Ayala
Housekeeper

Seth Barrish
Brooke's Dad (voice)
Amanda Gates-Ellison
Advisor

Charlie Gillette
Carey (uncredited)