Toby vs. Jeff: Creepypasta fan film: Cast
Carolyn Myers
Toby fan girl (voice)
Zac Cisco
Jeffry Woods
Tiernan Lachmann
Toby Rogers
Ella Hamblin
Girl
Derek Mason
Girl's father
Tracey Richmond
Tina Rucket
Liz Wolf
Camper #1 (Josh)
Zac Cisco
Camper #2 (Liu)
Tristan Osterberger
Victim watching TV
Sophie
Cat